Philosophy

Zen Buddhism (and Why I Should Probably Stop Reading The Bible On My Phone)

Ideas and reflections from a summer voyage to Japan

Zen Buddhism (and Why I Should Probably Stop Reading The Bible On My Phone)
Bamboo forest in Kyoto, Japan.

A few weeks ago I came across an Instagram Reel where a man was over-analyzing why Chinese teacups don't have handles, something about how the discomfort of holding hot porcelain connects you to the practice of mindfulness. Another creator responded by basically dismantling the theory. Turns out the handle-less design was just a design, it's quite often that the West has a fascination of over-reading mysticism into anything East Asian that it doesn't fully understand. I myself have been a victim of this. 

I think the second creator was right. But I also think there's a real question buried under the first creator's thoughts, and it's one worth taking seriously rather than mocking. Here in the West we tend to treat Asian philosophical traditions as bottomless wells of meaning while treating Asian technological and design advancements as merely functional, as if depth and utility can't come from the same civilization at the same time. So consider this my attempt to over-analyze carefully, in both directions, (and through my own experiences in Japan) rather than lazily in one. 

Why does a work of art draw more consideration than something as trivial as a mug, pencil, or dishrag? Why are certain actions in life placed as more important than others? This is the question of the field of "everyday aesthetics," an area of philosophy which focuses its attention on the study and appreciation of sensory, emotional, and artistic qualities in mundane, daily life. Although it is not exclusive to one culture, this area of thought is often associated with Japan, as Japanese philosophers have been working with these ideas within their own tradition for a long time. Yuriko Saito, a Japanese-American philosopher and professor at the Rhode Island School of Design, is a prominent figure here, describing everyday aesthetics as "any reactions we form toward the sensuous and/or design qualities of any object, phenomenon, or activity." 

I came to this question as a university student who (last year) finished a course on the subject. This caused me to think about how these concepts land in our actual modern lives. Mindfulness, presence, "the art of slowing down," these are terms that get thrown around in the digital landscape without much substance behind them. I, and many of my peers, experience mindfulness as something packaged and distributed by companies, rather than a concept attained through daily practice. But in reading The Book of Tea by Okakura Kakuzō (also known as Okakura Tenshin), I found a different perspective, one that might lead toward a more impactful answer. 

Tenshin argues that "Teaism," what he calls "a cult founded on the adoration of the beautiful among the sordid facts of everyday existence," is a kind of worship of the mindfulness that occurs during the drinking of tea. He writes that tea is more than a drink: "It is the only Asiatic ceremonial which commands universal esteem. The white man has scoffed at our religion and our morals, but has accepted the brown beverage without hesitation. The afternoon tea is now an important function in Western society." The tea ceremony, in other words, is an act that promotes mindfulness, simplicity, and the beauty of mundane life, across borders, regardless of whether the West understood or respected the rest of the philosophy that produced it. 

This all concluded, for me, in my own mindful action, because it was in reading itself that I found my answer. As I read these works, I realized that reading serves as a true appreciation of the everyday: books in themselves are everyday objects, created for normal people, that combine both Saito's tactile, sensuous experience and Tenshin's mindful concept of Teaism. Reading, specifically reading that brings the combination of joy and knowledge, could serve as a mirror of the guided tea ceremonies of Japan, a kind of "book ceremony": an act that helps us cross the threshold between living and mindful living. This is especially true for Christians, as reading the bible is an often ceremonial experience for us. As we enter our favorite reading nooks and open the word with a quiet reverence that places our soul in a position of praise and receiving. I’d argue that the way in which we read matters here, is it on a phone or is it the beautifully worn bible we’ve had for ages with years of highlights and notes. The content doesn’t change but like Virgil Abloh would once said “everything else around it does."

But coming back to the prompt, the question still remains. Why does a work of art draw more consideration than the trivial? For the same reason we limit our ceremonial emphasis to only a select number of items. Because we have not chosen to do otherwise. Expanding our framework for the sorts of objects that warrant this special, ceremonial consideration, to include everyday things, might allow us to live more mindfully, to attend to the present with greater respect. 

Should all things be considered, then? To give ceremonial respect toward an item is to grant something that normally would not be deemed worthy a great deal of consideration. Life is full of actions, waking and non-waking, that command very little respect simply because they were not designed with respect in mind. Some items are meant to be forgotten, or only noticed when their quality exceeds what we expect of them. Take an extremely soft napkin, or toilet paper, items meant to be thrown away that lose all value once used, with little attention paid to them beyond their basic function. It's not exactly common to meditate on the use of toilet paper. But take that same object and elevate its quality beyond what's considered normal, and more often than not the user will stop and notice, thinking about, feeling, the quality, even giving a quiet nod to the designers behind it. Even though the lifecycle of paperware is to be thrown away, we can still admire simple items the moment something outside ourselves prompts us to. 

Can the mere fact that an item is produced to be discarded disqualify it from ceremonial respect? All actions are fleeting, even when the object, a teacup, or a bible, is semi-permanent. Tea ceases to exist once drunk. Words fail to remain new once read. Tenshin writes, "we must remember, however, that art is of value only to the extent that it speaks to us. It might be a universal language if we ourselves were universal in our sympathies." Everyone experiences differently, one man's tea ceremony is undoubtedly another man's never-ending tug of war. 

Side streets in Kyoto

I felt this directly, and unpredictably, on our honeymoon, in Kyoto. My wife and I romantically parading as lovers around rainy side streets, dotting in and out of cafes, art galleries, and museums, and navigating the highly aesthetic and surreal experience that is ones first time in Japan (and namely Asia as a whole) that somewhere in the middle of the trip we found ourselves stumbling up the steps of Nanzen-ji and into what (i presume to be) the middle of a Buddhist service, which was my first real contact with the religion up close. Watching this service piqued my interest and pursued me to pick up a small text on Zen Buddhism at a bookstore in Narita Airport on our way out of Tokyo. I went in with no expectation and left with no more knowledge about the faith then I had before. But the service did cause me to slow down and focus for the few minutes we observed it. And that's the thing about presence, it cannot be pigeonholed, cannot be assigned in advance. No company, no creator on a Reel, no over-explained teacup design, (no person like me rambling thoughts on the internet) can guarantee that a given object or action will produce mindfulness on cue. To maintain that belief honestly, we have to widen our thought horizons to admit that anything might become a ceremony, under the right conditions, and that we can't always predict which thing or which moment will do it. 

Ceremony, simply defined, is "a formal act, ritual, or series of actions performed for a special occasion, often marked by tradition or religious significance." These are established, pre-thought preparations, often with unchanging elements, which is a fairly natural extension of the definition of ceremony, even if no one would call it religious. Although I don’t do it as often as I should, my personal reading time has become one of those ceremonies in my own life. Applying the same kind of set-apart practice to my reading time that a Zen Buddhist applies to tea, or that a Catholic monk applies to prayer, has brought me closer to the text I'm consuming (whether religious or non religious), to the process of reading itself, and even to the physical books, to the point that I find I can enter that same mindful "flow state" with text on a screen as I can with a physical book in hand. I don't think I'm unusual in this, and I don't think the world of varying, beautiful, everyday happenings is naturally limited to the handful of things we've already agreed to call ceremony. Naming our occurrences, setting aside our grievances, directing our attention toward what brings us closer to mindfulness, or at times, mindlessness, is how we make space in our finite minds for moments and memories that actually serve us. The framework for ceremony is only as limited as what we allow ourselves to believe is worthy of exceptional consideration. 

I write all of this as a Christian, which is the lens I can't fully set down even when I'm admiring someone else's tradition. Watching that service in Kyoto, I didn't feel the pull to convert, but I did recognize the hunger underneath it, the same hunger I'd just spent paragraphs describing in a quiet reading chair. Tenshin, Saito, the Buddhist monks in Kyoto, the man on the Reel fumbling toward something true about teacups, all of them are circling the same basic human need to mark some moments as worthy of full attention. Where I'd part ways, as a Christian, isn't on the value of that impulse. I think it's real, and worth defending against companies that try to bottle and sell it back to us. It's on what the attention is ultimately for. A Buddhist or Shinto ceremony asks you to be fully present in the moment, often as the whole point. A Christian church service asks you to be fully present in the moment because the moment is pointing past itself, toward something it can't contain. Both demand the same discipline of attention. They disagree about where that attention finally rests. 

I don't think that disagreement cancels out everything Tenshin or Saito have to offer. If anything, it raises the stakes on their argument: if presence is worth this much care across traditions that don't agree on metaphysics, it's probably worth more care than any of us, East or West, religious or not, are currently giving it.